![]() |
| Cruise ship in Sidney harbour |
Cruise Ship labour law exemptions extend Maritime
Worker Pain
By Owen Hsieh
The Australian Government recently announced it
is continuing the exemption from the Coastal Trading (Revitalising
Australian Shipping) Act 2012 for eligible cruise operators until 2028.
This exemption applies to eligible cruise vessels carrying passengers to and
from any Australian ports, except between Victoria and Tasmania.
Under this arrangement ships registered overseas
in foreign ports, under flag of convenience arrangements, can operate in
Australian waters with a ministerial exemption to Australian maritime
employment laws. The exemption has been extended with only token measures to
alleviate concerns, noting that workers are protected from victimisation when
participating in collective bargaining or when reporting hazards and incidents
to the regulator.
According to the Federal Infrastructure and
Transport Minister Catherine King[1]:
“The Albanese Government supports a thriving
maritime industry with strong protections for its workers, which is why we have
updated the Coastal Trading Act exemption for cruise ships.”
“Cruise tourism is an important driver of
economic growth in Australia. We want the cruise industry to keep thriving and
showcasing our country’s diverse regions to both local and international
visitors.”
“This means ensuring a fair go for the
hard-working seafarers who make cruising holidays possible for Australians,
while continuing the exemption to support the cruise tourism industry and our
port towns that rely on it.”
In reality, this mealy-mouthed high level
ministerial statement does nothing to support these maritime workers.
Mistreatment and victimisation will continue unabated far from the jurisdiction
of any regulatory authority. The international cruise ship industry has made
billions of dollars in profit, while paying their workers as little as $2.50
per hour. Workers are routinely working up to 16 hours per day, with long
rotations of up to 30 days in a row without a day off on 9-month long contracts.
These conditions have been, quite rightly, likened to modern-day slavery.
In august, an ABC news investigation in Australia
exposed terrible conditions onboard the ships, with workers highlighting the
issue of cramped, unsanitary living conditions and substandard food and drink
for staff. The investigation noted that food from passengers is not thrown out
and is passed down to workers, staff eat the leftovers of the leftovers and
that gastroenteritis and other illnesses were rife. It was also claimed that
there is inadequate medical treatment for staff and that the cruise ship
operators engage in victimisation and other forms of oppressive conduct when
workers take sick leave or raise issues.
In response to this litany of issues and the
ministerial statement, the Maritime Union of Australia National Secretary Jake
Field has noted
“International cruise companies like Carnival
make hundreds of millions of dollars in Australian waters by exploiting
international seafarers below decks and behind closed doors far beyond the
scrutiny of the public, and they have been doing this with a permission slip
from successive Federal Governments that allows them to avoid employing
Australian seafarers, something that we have always said has never been fit for
purpose”
“All of this is done in the name of providing an
enjoyable, unforgettable holiday experience to Australians in our own country
but comes at the price of pervasive, mass scale human suffering… …In no other
domestic industry would this abuse, exploitation and mistreatment be accepted
in our community or on or along our shorelines.”
Anticipating this criticism, the Albanese
Government has tepidly stated its intent for this to be the last exemption, and
that broader reforms are being progressed. A hollow, non-binding
statement that bears no positive outcomes for the maritime workers. Meanwhile,
this “final” labour law exemption will allow the exploitation and mistreatment
of foreign workers in Australian waters to continue unchecked.
Catherine King and the ALP are selling the
conditions and rights of foreign workers up the river and buoying up the
profits of Carnival Cruises. This does not pass the pub test and cannot
reasonably be accepted as a reasonable business model. Workers are denied
coverage under Australian employment law and paid a pittance while the cruise
ship operated in one of the wealthiest countries on earth.
According to a recent report from Forbes[3]:
“Australia occupies an enviable position in
global wealth rankings.
In 2025, the UBS Global Wealth Report placed
Australia second for median wealth per adult, behind only Luxembourg. Exclude
the Grand Duchy (which has a population smaller than the Gold Coast and the
world’s highest concentration of millionaires), and Australia is on top of the
world.”
Cruise ship operators are making large profits
operating in the Australian market. A short cruise can cost ~$1000 and an
extended or luxury voyage can routinely run past $10,000 per ticket. A brief
examination of online ticket prices exposes the insanity of the labour law
exemption further:
Regent Seven Seas Seven Seas Navigator: 24-Night
Australia/New Zealand Cruise from Sydney on Sep 20, 2027
One passenger travelling on the deluxe veranda
suite would pay $29,135.75 AUD pp, the signature suite is $59,598.00 AUD
pp.
To say that the labour law exemption is necessary is a bold-faced lie. The
long-term legal protections enabling multinational cruise ship operators to
reap super profits with the mistreatment and underpayment of foreign workers is
not necessary to support a thriving maritime industry.
The rights of the cruise ship workers have been
taken up with some incisive commentary from MUA. However, there is a disparity
between the low-income foreign workers on the cruise ships and the majority of
higher income workers employed by the MUA. According to an Australian
Financial Review article[4]
of 2021, the MUA was pushing for an agreement covering Stevedores and Wharfies
of between $118 K for an entry level position, and senior positions of up to
$162 K. A senior dockworker has the potential to earn nearly 3
times Australia’s median total personal income of $58,216.
The MUA is currently campaigning against
redundancies associated with the use of AI and automation at Australia’s ports.
They have aligned with international unions and pledged coordinated action in a
joint statement[5]
wherever “automation being used to destroy jobs, undermine unions and drive
down safety and employment standards on the waterfront”. The MUA has taken up
the struggle of cruise ship workers, but in all likelihood it will retreat back
to representing the most skilled and better paid layers in the maritime
industry with strong bargaining power based on their power at Australia's
ports.
The mass media in Australia has fallen into line
behind the official government propaganda, portraying the Transport Minister’s
decision as a toughening of the labour law that will protect maritime
workers.
For instance, take this headline: Updated
Cruise Exemption Strengthens Seafarer Protections.
The line that the exemption was somehow
strengthening the rights of seafarers was also embraced by the Maritime Union,
whose headline read: Cruise
Ship Sector on Notice to Deliver Basic Legal Protections to Vulnerable Crew
However, ABC news was somewhat more honest,
featuring a headline reading, “Cruise
ship crews still vulnerable to exploitation as government announces updated
protections.”
Perhaps that is not so surprising considering
that it was an investigation by ABC journalists that exposed the conditions of
cruise ship workers in the first place.
A more honest assessment of the important of the transport minister’s decision
came from a cruise ship industry outlet: Cruise
ships win two year exemption from restrictive maritime laws as government
acknowledges industry as “economic driver”
Nothing about strengthening the rights of seafarers here! Just recognition and
relief that the cruise ship industry has been let off the hook for at least
another 2 years!
What the working class in Australia need today is
a new leadership to combat the double dealing of the Labour Party and the union
bureaucrats. Where the Labour Party and the MUA talk out of both side of their
mouth and fail to represent either foreign workers or native-born workers in
Australia’s maritime industry, socialists who are steeped in the history of the
workers movement and the tradition of genuine class struggle should step in and
fill the void.
[1]
Catherine King MP, Updated cruise exemption to strengthen seafarer protections,
https://minister.infrastructure.gov.au/c-king/media-release/updated-cruise-exemption-strengthen-seafarer-protections
[2]
Maritime Union of Australia, Cruise Ship Sector on Notice to Deliver Basic
Legal Protections to Vulnerable Crew, https://www.mua.org.au/MUA/Content/News_Articles/2026/cruise-ship-sector-on-notice-to-deliver-basic-legal-protections-to-vulnerable-crew.aspx
[3]
Forbes, How rich are Australians, really?, https://www.forbes.com.au/covers/magazine/how-rich-are-australians-really/
[4]
Australian Financial Review, MUA pushes for $119k minimum wage, https://www.afr.com/work-and-careers/workplace/mua-pushes-for-119k-minimum-wage-20210202-p56yrr
[5]
Maritime Union of Australia, MUA and International Dockworkers Unite to Fight
Automation and Defend Waterfront Jobs, https://www.mua.org.au/MUA/Content/News_Articles/2026/mua-and-international-dockworkers-unite-to-fight-automation-and-defend-waterfront-jobs.aspx

.png)







No comments:
Post a Comment